The
Austin American Statesman published an opinion titled “Plan for single sex schoolsin East Austin is another pricey experiment” on February 2, 2013. The writer of
the editorial is critical about the Austin school trustees who voted to approve
single-sex schools for Pearce and Garcia middle schools. In this editorial, the
writer’s intended audiences are the parents, taxpayer, and homeowner of Pearce
and Garcia. The writer claims that the trustees’ votes were not based on solid
research, financial feasibility or models with a proven track record of success.
According to the editorial, Pearce and Garcia has been rated academically
unacceptable by the state in three of the past four years and the trustees
considered that single-sex school would be the best practices for educating these
unban minority students in Pearce and Garcia. The writer claims that the
trustees approved attendance-zoned single-sex schools without having solid
evidence that “those models have successfully affected academic performance of
minority students in urban districts”. Instead they focused on the
insignificant point that wearing uniforms or studying in single-sex environment
offer fewer distractions.
I
think the writer makes a valid point that single-sex school is not a solution
to improve the academic performance of the urban minority students. Although I
think the writer fails to mention the root cause of the poor performance of the
students from these areas. In reality, most of the urban minority families don’t
put value to their children’s education. Also the writer did not mention about
the disadvantages of single-sex schools which is, single-sex schools promote gender stereotype and limit students abilities to successfully interact
with members of opposite sex.
The
point I fully agree with the writer is that single sex-schools are more
expensive to run than co-ed schools because it requires separate campuses for
both genders.
In
conclusion, single-sex school is not a solution to improve urban minority
areas’ education. What they need to do is to get the parents motivate about
the importance of their children’s education and also make sure to recruit
skilled teachers in those schools.